Loved ones of a woman from Windsor are requesting the removal of photos depicting her during a period of drug addiction from social media. The woman, identified as Alicia Newman, passed away a few years ago, and her family finds the images distressing, preferring that she be remembered differently. Despite their attempts to contact the photographer to have the photos removed, the family has faced unresponsiveness and blocks.
Alicia’s twin brother, Devin Newman, recollects how he admired his sister, describing her as a kind-hearted individual. Following a car accident while residing in Paris, Ont., Alicia’s life took a challenging turn when she got involved with drugs, leading to a downward spiral. Upon relocating to Windsor in her late twenties, Alicia struggled with drug addiction, homelessness, and mental health issues. Tragically, in 2018, Alicia passed away due to complications related to drug use at the age of 37.
The family first encountered the photos of Alicia online a year after her passing, posted by photographer Donnie Johnston. These images depict Alicia with short blonde hair in various settings, including a parking lot, and one photo insinuating she was a sex worker. Despite efforts to communicate with Johnston, the family received no response initially, but the caption was eventually removed.
Over the years, Johnston has reposted Alicia’s photos on social media, prompting the family to report the images on Facebook without success. The family expressed deep emotional distress upon seeing the photos, feeling violated and saddened by the portrayal of Alicia during a vulnerable period in her life. Concerns were also raised regarding other graphic photos on Johnston’s page.
The family is adamant that Alicia did not provide consent for the photos, especially given her struggles with bipolar disorder. By sharing their story, the family aims to reclaim Alicia’s narrative and prevent others from exploitation online. They underscore the need for stronger legal protections for vulnerable individuals facing similar situations.
In Canada, it is generally legal to take and post photos in public spaces, posing challenges for privacy protection. Legal experts emphasize the importance of nuanced laws that consider the privacy rights of individuals, particularly those experiencing homelessness. Calls for legal reforms to safeguard dignity and image control in the digital era are intensifying.
Addressing the ethical aspects of street photography, a photography expert stresses the significance of respecting subjects’ dignity and consent, particularly in vulnerable communities like the unhoused. While street photography can raise awareness, ethical considerations regarding privacy and dignity must be prioritized. Alicia’s family continues to advocate for the removal of the photos, feeling overwhelmed by the lack of options and hoping to honor Alicia’s memory with dignity.
